by Michael Buzzelli
“He stretched out his arms toward the dark water in a curious way, and, as far as I was from him, I could have sworn he was trembling. Involuntarily I glanced seaward—and distinguished nothing except a single green light, minute and far away, that might have been at the end of a dock.” – F. Scott Fitzgerald
When World War One (called the Great War since WWII hadn’t happened yet) vet Nick Carraway (Joshua Grosso) moves to New York, he meets the enigmatic millionaire Jay Gatsby (Jake David Smith), and his life changes forever in “The Great Gatsby – A New Musical.”
The titular character and his exploits are based on an American Classic by F. Scott Fitzgerald, required reading in high school from sea to shining sea.
Side note: You, dear reader, probably already know this.
Gatsby is in love with Nick’s cousin, Daisy (Senzel Ahmady), who, unfortunately, is married to Tom Buchanan (Will Branner). Daisy introduces Nick to Jordan Baker (Leanne Robinson), a tennis star who lives in the Buchanans’ guest house (just as Nick is living in Gatsby’s guest house).
Since it’s the Roarin’ 20s, morals are loose, and the bathtub gin is flowing. Tom has an affair with a married woman, Myrtle (Lila Coogan). When Nick sees the detestable Tom carry on behind his cousin’s back, he arranges a meeting between Daisy and Gatsby. The two had met years before the war and were madly in love, but status and the Great War prevented them from cementing a matrimonial union.
Meanwhile, the shady Meyer Wolfsheim (Edward Staudenmayer) is using a gas station owned by George Wilson (Tally Sessions) to run his illegal activities. In an amazing coincidence, George is married to Myrtle, Tom’s side piece.
If you haven’t read the book or seen the countless movie adaptations, you will be shocked by the turn of events that come roaring on. No spoilers.

“The Great Gatsby” is the tentpole of a fantastic circus, a brilliant story with, literal and figurative, fireworks. The entire production is a spectacle.
Since the story is about the crazy excesses of the 20s, all the excesses are on full display. There is the most beautiful scenery by Paul Tate dePoo II, with equally impressive projection design (also by dePoo). There are glorious costumes by Linda Cho (frilly, sparkling numbers that dazzle under Cory Pattak’s incredible lighting). The choreography, by Dominque Kelley, is astonishing as the chorus gyrates to Jason Howland’s delightful score.
Director Marc Bruni does a superb job of keeping the source material as poetic as intended.
A few songs are memorable, but they’re not songs you will be humming on the way to the parking garage. That said, the acting and singing were among the best.
The main cast each gets a moment to shine, and they all shine brightly.
Grosso’s comical acrobatics in “The Met” are spectacular. He slinks over the furniture like a rubber snake. He has a powerful vocal instrument.
Smith is oozing charisma (it’s a Gatsby requirement and he meets it with aplomb).
Robinson is a belter of the highest order. She gets to hit some amazing high notes. Jordan’s role seems expanded here, and it’s a wonderful choice that gives a stronger female presence in a male-dominated story.
Despite this reviewer’s dislike of Daisy Buchanan as a character, Ahmady gives a fantastic portrayal. She gives the character more depth than she deserves, and charms the entire audience (this Daisy hater included).
Note: Daisy defenders are welcome to comment (but I will play the Hit-and-Run card).
Unlike most musicals, there is a depth behind the pomp and circumstance. It’s not just visual cotton candy (though this show has visual delights to satisfy every appetite). The story is universal. It’s a tale of love and jealousy. It shows the rich and the poor, both struggling with matters of the heart.
“The Great Gatsby” reminds us that the heart and the soul can be far apart on a variety of issues.
If you want to instill the love of theater in a young mind (or any mind), this is the show that reminds you why “The Great Gatsby” is an American classic, and you’ll have a blast while sharing the story.
-MB
“The Great Gatsby” runs from Tue, May 26 – Sun, May 31, 2026, at the Benedum Center, Seventh Street and Penn Avenues, Pittsburgh, PA 15222. For tickets and additional information, click here.
















